Navigating the world of violin bows can be daunting, especially when you’re seeking an upgrade without breaking the bank. For many musicians, a budget of around 3,000 euros represents a significant investment, opening up a range of quality options. In a recent online discussion, a violinist named Saïdjah initiated a search for bow recommendations within this price range, sparking a helpful conversation among fellow players. This article delves into the insights shared, offering guidance for anyone looking to find a superb violin bow for under 3,000 euros.
Expert Recommendations: Bow Makers Under €3,000
The discussion quickly highlighted several reputable bow makers and categories to consider when shopping for a violin bow in the 3,000 euro price range. Here’s a breakdown of the recommendations:
French Bow Makers
Gilles Nehr was enthusiastically recommended as a “brilliant bowmaker” crafting bows inspired by legendary makers like Tourte, Persois, and Pajeot. Known for first-rate craftsmanship and high-quality materials, Gilles Nehr’s bows are worth exploring. His website, www.gillesnehr.com, provides a visual showcase of his work, including model #12 which was specifically praised in the forum.
Edwin Clement in Paris was another French maker mentioned, lauded for producing “fantastic” bows. While noted as slightly more expensive with a potential waiting list at the time of the discussion (2006), Clement’s bows are clearly held in high regard and represent a worthwhile option to investigate if seeking a French-style bow.
Pierre Guillaume, located in the same general region as the original poster, was also suggested. While the original poster’s personal experience with Guillaume bows was mixed, it was acknowledged that others had found excellent bows from this maker. This highlights the subjective nature of bow selection – what works exceptionally well for one player might not be the ideal fit for another.
German Bow Makers
Several German bow makers were brought up as excellent alternatives, often offering great value within the 3,000 euro budget. Durschmidt, Pfretzschner, and Nurnberger bows were specifically named as German bows offering “good value for their money.” These makers represent a tradition of German bow making known for solid craftsmanship and reliability.
Otto Hoyer bows were also mentioned as “fine old German bows.” While opinions varied on whether older German bows were the absolute best choice in this price range compared to modern makers, they are certainly worth considering, particularly if you appreciate the characteristics of older instruments.
Tino Lücke, a modern German maker praised for being “very French inspired,” was highlighted as an “excellent maker” whose bows were still available for under 3,000 euros, despite winning awards. His website, www.lochmann-lucke.de, could offer further insight into his current offerings.
Modern Bow Makers
The discussion leaned towards recommending contemporary bow makers for the 3,000 euro price point. Experienced players suggested that “there are much better bows made by great contemporary makers than some old bows” in this price range. The advancements in bow making and the consistent quality available from modern makers were seen as significant advantages.
Sylvain Bigot (French) and Tino Lücke (German) are examples of modern makers specifically mentioned as producing superb bows that could be acquired within the budget. Exploring contemporary makers allows access to potentially innovative designs and consistently high standards of craftsmanship.
Carbon Fiber Bows: An Alternative
Carbon fiber bows, like the Arcus Sinfonia (around 1500 Euro) and Arcus Cadenza (around 4000 Euro), were presented as viable alternatives to traditional pernambuco wood bows. Arcus bows are known for their lightness and responsiveness. While some players prefer the feel and tradition of wood bows, carbon fiber options have advanced significantly and can offer excellent playing characteristics, sometimes at a more accessible price point.
The Arcos Brazil brand was also mentioned as offering “really excellent economical stuff.” While potentially requiring sifting through a selection to find the perfect match, Arcos Brazil bows are praised for their consistent quality and value.
Old vs. New Bows: A Key Consideration
A recurring theme in the discussion was the comparison between old and new bows. While acknowledging the allure of older bows, particularly French and German master bows, the consensus leaned towards modern bows offering superior value and playability within the 3,000 euro budget.
It was suggested that for under 3,000 euros, finding an exceptional example of an old master bow might be challenging. Reputable shops are more likely to house genuine older master bows, but these often come with a significantly higher price tag. For this budget, exploring contemporary makers might yield a more rewarding instrument in terms of responsiveness and overall quality.
Essential Qualities of a Good Violin Bow
The forum touched upon what makes a violin bow “good” or “bad.” Responsiveness and grace were highlighted as key qualities that distinguish higher-quality bows. A finer bow responds more readily to subtle changes in pressure and speed, allowing for greater nuance and control in playing.
The discussion mentioned Voirin bows as examples of bows known for their grace and responsiveness, though typically priced well above 3,000 euros. While a bow in the 3,000 euro range may not reach the same level of refinement as a Voirin, understanding these desirable qualities helps in evaluating bows and identifying those that offer superior playability within the budget.
Where to Find Your Bow in Europe
For those located in Europe, or willing to travel, several locations and shops were suggested. Visiting Mirecourt in France, a historical center of French bow making, was proposed as a potential destination to find bows. However, it was also noted that reputable shops in larger cities like Paris, such as J.F. Raffin and Le Canu (formerly Millant shop), are more likely to stock a wider selection of high-quality old and new bows.
For those unable to travel, the internet and mail-order were presented as viable options. It was pointed out that makers like Sylvain Bigot and Tino Lücke are accessible even if you are not located nearby, suggesting that exploring makers online and potentially arranging trials through mail could expand your search beyond local shops.
Final Thoughts & Recommendations
Finding the right violin bow is a personal journey. While 3,000 euros opens doors to excellent options, the “best” bow is ultimately the one that feels and plays best for you. Based on the expert discussion, here are key takeaways for your search:
- Explore modern makers: Contemporary bow makers often offer exceptional quality and value in the 3,000 euro range.
- Consider German and French bows: Both traditions offer excellent craftsmanship; German bows may provide great value, while French bows are often admired for their refinement.
- Don’t dismiss carbon fiber: Carbon fiber bows are a worthy alternative, offering different playing characteristics and potentially good value.
- Focus on responsiveness and feel: Prioritize bows that respond well to your playing and feel comfortable in your hand.
- Try before you buy: Whenever possible, try multiple bows to compare and find the best fit for your playing style.
- Seek expert advice: Consult with your teacher or experienced players for guidance in your bow selection process.
By considering these recommendations and exploring the makers and bow types mentioned, you’ll be well-equipped to find a fantastic violin bow under 3,000 euros that enhances your musical journey.
