Angler demonstrating Euro nymphing technique
Having spent my formative years fly fishing in the renowned tailwaters of the American West, I dedicated myself to mastering the art of enticing the most selective trout with diminutive flies. Immersed in this demanding environment, I became a staunch advocate of suspension or strike indicator nymph fishing, occasionally incorporating indicatorless sight fishing. For a long time, I was convinced of its unparalleled effectiveness for catching significant numbers of fish in most trout rivers. However, recent experiences have challenged this long-held belief.
My perspective began to shift in 2005 when I started working alongside Lance Egan and Ryan Barnes, both members of Fly Fishing Team USA. The competitive fly fishing arena they were involved in sparked my curiosity, particularly the aspiration to represent my country in international competitions. There was a significant hurdle: my preferred split shot and indicator method was prohibited in FIPS Mouche sanctioned events like the World Fly Fishing Championships. This regulation necessitated a fundamental reassessment and adaptation of my nymphing strategy, pushing me to explore alternative, yet equally effective, approaches. Fortuitously, Lance and Ryan became invaluable mentors, introducing me to the long French leader style of European nymphing, a technique Lance embraced after the 2007 World Fly Fishing Championships in Portugal. Now, after over a decade of competing with Fly Fishing Team USA, numerous on-water comparisons, and achieving both team and individual medals at the World Fly Fishing Championships, I am firmly persuaded that European style nymphing surpasses strike indicator or suspension nymphing in efficacy across a wide spectrum of water types.
To better understand the rationale behind my conviction regarding the enhanced effectiveness of European nymphing techniques, I encourage you to watch the video excerpt embedded below from our film, Modern Nymphing: European Inspired Tactics, recently launched by Lance Egan, Gilbert Rowley, and myself. For a more detailed analysis, the following points outline what I perceive as the key advantages and disadvantages of European nymphing compared to suspension or strike indicator nymphing.
The Merits of Euro Nymphing Techniques
- Enhanced Strike Detection Through Direct Contact: Euro nymphing excels in strike detection due to its direct connection to the flies. The absence of mending ensures constant readiness to set the hook. In contrast, strike indicator nymphing requires the rig to sink and achieve tension to register a strike, and the indicator must remain within the same current seam to maintain an optimal drift and strike detection. Slack often develops between the indicator and flies, diminishing strike sensitivity, and flies frequently drift into current seams moving at different speeds or directions than the indicator. This disparity disrupts the drift and compromises strike detection. Furthermore, continuous mending can delay hook sets, potentially allowing fish to eject the fly before a solid connection is made.
Close-up of Euro nymphing sighter for strike detection
-
Minimized Drag for Superior Drifts: Strike indicators can act like kites in surface currents, pulling the rig at a different pace and direction than the bottom currents where the nymphs are positioned. The Euro nymphing rig, with only tippet on or in the water, minimizes drag from surface currents that diverge from the speed or direction of the drifting fly. Improved drifts translate directly to more fish, particularly in complex water environments characterized by fast current speeds and turbulence. This advantage is particularly pronounced in pocket water and eddies, where a strike indicator might land in a current seam flowing in the opposite direction of the flies. When Euro nymphing in such pocket water, keeping the sighter (a built-in monofilament strike indicator) off the water eliminates the issue of conflicting currents that induce drag between nymphs and a strike indicator.
-
Reduced Surface Disturbance for Less Spooked Fish: Indicators create significant surface disturbances upon landing, mending, and hook sets. Long leader Euro nymphing rigs, in contrast, present delicately on the water and lift off with minimal disturbance during hook sets. Less surface disturbance equates to fewer spooked fish, especially in clear and shallow waters where trout are easily alarmed.
-
Improved Hooked-to-Landed Ratio: Euro nymphing offers a better fish hooked-to-landed ratio due to reduced slack in the system and a higher proportion of strikes occurring at close range and fewer downstream. Strike indicator rigs, while enabling longer drifts, often suffer from inefficient initial drift phases as the rig sinks and aligns before tension and strike detection are achieved. Consequently, many takes occur in the latter part of the drift when using a strike indicator. This results in less favorable hooking angles and increased lost fish rates.
-
Efficient and Rapid Depth Adjustment: With a Euro nymphing setup, depth control is effortlessly managed by adjusting the amount of leader in the water. Quick fly changes allow for weight adjustments, further refining depth manipulation. There is no need to reposition indicators or repeatedly add or remove split shot to adapt to varying depths and current speeds encountered on the river. This adaptability allows anglers to effectively fish water from mere inches to several feet deep without altering the fundamental rig.
-
Enhanced Ability to Induce Takes: Euro nymphing facilitates easy fly movement to induce takes with a simple rod lift. This technique can be exceptionally effective during insect emergences or when fish have become accustomed to dead drifts. Inducing movement with suspension nymphing necessitates moving the indicator, which generates surface disturbance and can drag the indicator laterally across the river into current seams different from the flies’ drift path.
The Limitations of Euro Nymphing
-
Reduced Presentation Radius for Distance Fishing: Indicators allow for a greater presentation radius, enabling fishing at distances beyond the reach of Euro nymphing techniques. This is advantageous in deep or clear water where maintaining close proximity to fish is challenging or impossible.
-
Superior Drifts in Uniform Slow Water: Indicators provide smoother fly suspension and potentially better drifts in slow-moving water with consistent depth. However, prolonged drifts in slow water with Euro nymphing can lead to shoulder fatigue and potential rod shake, introducing unnatural movement to the drift.
-
Weighting Challenges with Micro Flies: It can be difficult to incorporate sufficient weight into flies smaller than size 16 to effectively fish them at depth. To reach depths of more than a few feet with micro flies, it may be necessary to add a larger, heavier fly to the rig in conjunction with the smaller fly or flies to ensure proper sinking and presentation.
For those eager to delve deeper into the intricacies of Euro nymphing, we invite you to consider purchasing our film. You can preview the trailer and acquire the digital download on Vimeo for $19.99. The DVD version is also available for $29.99 at Tacticalflyfisher.com. Please find the links provided below.
